C of I vs. Carroll College

The College of Idaho and Carroll College side by side on admissions, cost, and outcomes, from public data.

The College of Idaho
Carroll College

At a glance

  • Harder to get into: C of I (49.1% admitted vs 70.9%). Typical SAT 1180 vs 1180.
  • Cheaper after aid: C of I. Average net price is $21,686 vs $25,575 at Carroll College.
  • Graduation: C of I 63% vs Carroll College 59%.
  • Earnings 10 years out: C of I $45,700 vs Carroll College $47,500 (median).
See your own chances ->
Acceptance rate
C of I more selective
C of I49.1%
Carroll College70.9%
SAT range (middle 50%)
Carroll College higher
C of I1070-1280
Carroll College1050-1300
Average net price
C of I $3,889 less
C of I$21,686
Carroll College$25,575
In-state tuition
C of I $3,639 less
C of I$37,845
Carroll College$41,484
Out-of-state tuition
C of I $3,639 less
C of I$37,845
Carroll College$41,484
Graduation rate
C of I +4 pts
C of I63%
Carroll College59%
Median earnings (10 years)
Carroll College +$1,800
C of I$45,700
Carroll College$47,500

Sources: IPEDS and College Scorecard.

Admission calculator

Partner

Not sure you'd get in? Check your chances at C of I and Carroll College with Appily's free admission calculator.

  • Applied
  • C of I 3,650
  • Carroll College 1,854
  • Admitted
  • C of I 1,792
  • Carroll College 1,315
  • Acceptance rate
  • C of I 49.1%
  • Carroll College 70.9%
  • Yield (share of admitted who enroll)
  • C of I 14.7%
  • Carroll College 21.6%
  • Typical SAT score
  • C of I 1180
  • Carroll College 1180
  • Typical ACT score
  • C of I 27
  • Carroll College 24
  • Average high school GPA
  • C of I -
  • Carroll College 3.64
  • Typical high school grades
  • C of I -
  • Carroll College A-
  • Admissions standards
  • C of I Difficult
  • Carroll College Average
  • Applicant competition
  • C of I Low
  • Carroll College Low
  • SAT range
  • C of I 1070-1280
  • Carroll College 1050-1300
  • ACT range
  • C of I 23-31
  • Carroll College 21-27
  • Submit test scores
  • C of I Test optional
  • Carroll College Test optional
  • Application deadline
  • C of I Feb 15, 2027
  • Carroll College Feb 28, 2027
  • Tuition (in state)
  • C of I $37,845
  • Carroll College $41,484
  • Tuition (out of state)
  • C of I $37,845
  • Carroll College $41,484
  • Room & board
  • C of I $12,773
  • Carroll College $11,548
  • Average net price
  • C of I $21,686
  • Carroll College $25,575
  • Average grant aid
  • C of I $29,110
  • Carroll College $30,058
  • % receiving grant aid
  • C of I 100%
  • Carroll College 100%
  • Graduation rate
  • C of I 63%
  • Carroll College 59%
  • Median earnings (after 10 years)
  • C of I $45,700
  • Carroll College $47,500
  • Making student loan payments
  • C of I 73%
  • Carroll College 81%
  • Median student loan debt
  • C of I $25,995
  • Carroll College $27,000
  • Median loan payment
  • C of I $268
  • Carroll College $279
  • Student to faculty ratio
  • C of I 10:1
  • Carroll College 12:1
  • Popular majors
  • C of I
    • Business (15%)
    • Visual and Performing Arts (14%)
    • Biology (13%)
    • Social Sciences (10%)
    • History (10%)
  • Carroll College
    • Business (15%)
    • Health Professions (14%)
    • Biology (11%)
    • Education (9%)
    • Psychology (7%)
  • Location
  • C of I Caldwell, ID
  • Carroll College Helena, MT
  • Setting
  • C of I Small Suburban
  • Carroll College Remote Town
  • Total enrollment
  • C of I 1,090
  • Carroll College 1,156
  • Type
  • C of I Private 4 Year
  • Carroll College Private 4 Year
  • National ranking
  • C of I #367
  • Carroll College #458

Comparable Facts

Compare The College of Idaho in Caldwell, ID with Carroll College in Helena, MT on tuition, admissions, graduation, earnings, and student body data using the tables above.

Carroll College is larger than C of I based on total student enrollment (1,156 students vs. 1,090 students).

Location, institution type, and student-faculty ratio

  • The College of Idaho is located in Caldwell, ID (Small Suburban setting); Carroll College is in Helena, MT (Remote Town setting).
  • The College of Idaho is a private, non-profit 4-year institution. Carroll College is a private, non-profit 4-year institution.
  • Student-to-faculty ratio: The College of Idaho 10:1; Carroll College 12:1.

Cost details

  • Living costs (room and board or off-campus housing budget) at Carroll College are 9.6% lower than at The College of Idaho ($11,548 vs. $12,773).
  • Out-of-state tuition is 9.6% higher at Carroll College than at The College of Idaho (about $3,639 more per year; $41,484 vs. $37,845).
  • The same share of students receive grant aid at The College of Idaho as at Carroll College (100% vs. 100%).
  • The average total grant financial aid received by Carroll College students is 3.3% larger than aid received by The College of Idaho students ($30,058 vs. $29,110).

Admissions details

  • Typical ACT composite is 3 points higher at C of I than at Carroll College (27 vs. 24, midpoint estimate).
  • SAT or ACT scores are test optional at both C of I and Carroll College.
  • Typical fall application deadline: C of I Feb 15, 2027; Carroll College Feb 28, 2027.
  • The share of admitted students who enrolled (yield) is 14.7% at C of I vs. 21.6% at Carroll College.

Loans and repayment

  • Among federal student loan borrowers, The College of Idaho graduates have a $1,005 lower median loan debt than Carroll College graduates ($25,995 vs. $27,000).
  • Among borrowers, C of I graduates have an estimated $11 lower median monthly federal student loan payment than Carroll College graduates ($268 vs. $279).
  • More Carroll College graduates are actively paying back their federal student loan debt than former C of I students, three years after graduation (81% vs. 73%).

Sources: U.S. Department of Education, IPEDS and College Scorecard. Values reflect the most recent year available in our dataset.

Change schools

You can add up to two more colleges. Each one gets its own column.

The College of Idaho
Carroll College
Add a college Compare up to 4

Frequently compared to these colleges