C of I vs. St. Mary's College

Should I go to The College of Idaho or Saint Mary's College? Compare 50+ facts and figures about the colleges to help you determine if C of I or St. Mary's College is the better college for you. The CollegeSimply comparison tool allows side-by-side comparison of 50+ statistics and facts for over 2,500 colleges and universities.
Add a college to compare up to four schools

Frequently compared to these colleges. Click a college to add to the comparison. 

Purdue Boise State Idaho Xavier University of Dayton Carroll College Hope College Bethel College-Mishawaka Butler Loyola Kentucky Marquette University
The College of Idaho vs. Saint Mary's College comparison
The College of Idaho Saint Mary's College College 3 College 4
The College of Idaho Saint Mary's College
Remove Remove +Add +Add

Overview

 C of I St. Mary's College
Location Caldwell, ID Notre Dame, IN
Setting Small Suburban Rural Fringe
Enrollment 1,082 1,519
Type Private 4 Year Private 4 Year
National Ranking #433 #162
Religious Affiliation - Roman Catholic - -
Status Non-profit Non-profit
Website collegeofidaho.edu saintmarys.edu
Team Colors                    

Costs

 C of I St. Mary's College
Tuition (In State) $33,825 $48,880
Tuition (Out of State) $33,825 $48,880
Room & Board $10,820 $13,580
Avg Net Price $24,075 $27,960
Avg Grant Aid $23,878 $36,112
% Receiving Grant Aid 100% 100%

Admission

 C of I St. Mary's College
Admission Chances Calculate Calculate
Applied 4,490 2,260
Admitted 2,044 1,896
Acceptance Rate 45.5% 83.9%
Enrolled % 13.2% 20.9%
Avg High School GPA - 3.83
Typical High School Grades - A-
Admissions Standards Challenging Difficult
Applicant Competition Low
ACT Range 23/29 26/32
SAT Range 1070/1240 1100/1328
Submit Test Scores Not required for admission, but considered if submitted (Test Optional) Not required for admission, but considered if submitted (Test Optional)
Application Deadline Feb 15, 2024

Academics

 C of I St. Mary's College
Student to Faculty Ratio 10:1 9:1
Popular Majors
  • Business (15%)
  • Visual and Performing Arts (14%)
  • Biology (13%)
  • Social Sciences (10%)
  • History (10%)
  • Health Professions (13%)
  • Communication (12%)
  • Business (10%)
  • English and Literature (9%)
  • Social Sciences (9%)

Outcomes

 C of I St. Mary's College
Graduation Rate 63% 79%
Median Earnings (After 10 years) $45,700 $51,100
Making Student Loan Payments 73% 85%
Median Student Loan Debt $25,995 $27,000
Median Loan Payment $268 $279

Diversity

 C of I St. Mary's College
% Men 49% 1%
% Women 51% 99%
Racial Diversity Medium Low
HBCU No No
% White 66% 78%
% Black 2% 2%
% Hispanic 14% 11%
% Native American 1% 0%
% Pacific Islander 1% 0%
% Two or More Races 3% 3%
% International 7% 1%
% Unknown Race 4% 3%

Students

 C of I St. Mary's College
% In-State 52% 35%
% Out-of-State 32% 64%

Campus

 C of I St. Mary's College
Campus Housing Yes Yes
Freshman Dorm Required No No
Meal Plan Yes Yes
Weekend/Evening Classes No No
Daycare Facility No Yes
Learn More Details Details

Comparable Facts

  • Saint Mary's College is larger than than C of I based on total student enrollment (1,519 students vs. 1,082 students)

C of I vs. St. Mary's College Cost Comparison

Which college is more expensive, C of I or St. Mary's College?

  • Saint Mary's College is 44.5% more expensive to attend than C of I for in-state tuition ($48,880.00 vs. $33,825.00)
  • Out of state tuition is 44.5% higher at St. Mary's College than The College of Idaho ($48,880.00 vs. $33,825.00)
  • The typical actual cost that students pay to attend (average net price) is less at The College of Idaho than St. Mary's College ($24,075 vs. $27,960)
  • Living costs (room and board or off-campus housing budget) at The College of Idaho are 25.5% lower than costs at Saint Mary's College ($10,820 vs. $13,580)
  • The same percent of students receive financial grant aid at The College of Idaho as Saint Mary's College (100% vs. 100%)
  • The average total grant financial aid received by Saint Mary's College students is 51.2% larger than aid received The College of Idaho ($36,112 vs. $23,878)

C of I vs. St. Mary's College Admissions Difficulty Comparison

Which college is harder to get into, C of I or St. Mary's College? Average SAT and ACT scores plus acceptance rates offer good insight into the difficulty of admission between St. Mary's College or C of I .

  • St. Mary's College has a higher acceptance rate (83.9%) than C of I (45.5%)

C of I vs. St. Mary's College Graduation Outcomes Comparison

Which is better, C of I or St. Mary's College? Graduation rate, salary and amount of student loan debt are indicators of a college which offers better outcomes for its graduates. Compare the following outcomes facts between St. Mary's College and C of I.

  • The graduation rate at St. Mary's College is higher than The College of Idaho (79% vs. 63%)
  • Graduates from Saint Mary's College earn on average $5,400 more per year than C of I graduates after ten years. ($51,100 vs. $45,700)
  • The College of Idaho students graduate with a $1,005 lower median federal student loan debt than St. Mary's College graduates. ($25,995 vs. $27,000)
  • C of I graduates are paying $11 less per month on federal student loans than St. Mary's College graduates. ($268 vs. $279)
  • More St. Mary's College graduates are actively paying back their federal student loan debt than former C of I students, three years after graduation. (85% vs. 73%)

Sources: U.S. Department of Education https://nces.ed.gov IPEDS and College Scorecard https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/